San Diego City Sidewalk Left in Dangerous Condition Led to Man’s TBI, Shattered Arm
Case Features
Government NegligenceJudgment
$4,800,000

San Diego City Sidewalk Left in Dangerous Condition Led to Man’s TBI, Shattered Arm

The City of San Diego ignored a known hazardous sidewalk condition, causing a man to trip and sustain a traumatic brain injury (TBI)

Watch the Case Feature
Open the case feature video

A victim’s body was slammed onto concrete after a nighttime trip-and-fall on a San Diego sidewalk. The collapse left the man, named Mark, with a shattered arm and a traumatic brain injury that would alter the course of his life forever. What should have been an ordinary walk home from dinner became a violent impact event with lasting physical and neurological consequences. The City of San Diego had long been aware of problems with that stretch of sidewalk, yet failed to correct the dangerous condition or protect the pedestrians who used it. Instead of addressing a known hazard, the City allowed the defect to remain in place for years, creating the conditions that led directly to Mark’s fall.

The consequences were severe. Mark’s arm was broken so badly that it required surgery, with 13 screws used to repair the damage. But the most difficult injury to fully understand was the invisible injury lurking under the skin. The blow to his head caused a traumatic brain injury that left him struggling with headaches, vertigo, and the kind of cognitive symptoms that can disrupt concentration, daily functioning, and quality of life. His records documented serious harm, but as in many brain injury cases, the full extent of what he suffered was not something that could be appreciated at a glance. What happened to Mark was not a routine sidewalk trip with a simple recovery. It was a catastrophic fall with lasting and deeply personal consequences.

Mark turned to attorney Daryoosh Khashayar of Khashayar Law Group in San Diego, who then brought in attorney Oliver Shami as co-counsel because of his extensive personal injury trial experience. Together, they understood the case would require much more than proving a fall had occurred. From the beginning, they saw that they would need to establish exactly where the incident happened, show why the City was responsible for the sidewalk condition, defeat attempts to shift blame elsewhere, and fully prove the extent of Mark’s injuries.

Their investigation and litigation efforts unfolded over years. Daryoosh and Oliver gathered records, worked with witnesses, and used historical Google imagery and other evidence to pinpoint the exact location of the fall. They developed proof showing that the City had knowledge of the dangerous area for years before Mark was injured. At the same time, they had to confront a shifting defense position that tried to redirect liability to others while disputing the mechanism of the fall itself. The attorneys also built out the medical side of the case, documenting not only the arm injury and resulting surgery, but also the much more difficult task of proving a traumatic brain injury whose symptoms could not simply be seen on the outside.

The defense fought hard on nearly every front. The City refused to accept responsibility and argued that Mark’s condition was the result of alcohol rather than a dangerous sidewalk, even though he had simply been walking home and had done the responsible thing by not driving. The defense also claimed he fell somewhere other than the location he identified and challenged whether his injuries — especially his brain injury and even the surgery to repair his arm — were as serious or as necessary as claimed. Even with those disputes unresolved, making clear that meaningful resolution would not happen without a fully prepared trial presentation.

Daryoosh and Oliver responded by building the case through expert testimony and carefully coordinated proof. They brought in a biomechanical and accident reconstruction expert to explain how the fall occurred and the forces involved. They used a safety expert to establish that the sidewalk condition was dangerous and that the City had not followed its own procedures and guidelines. They also relied on medical experts to prove the nature of Mark’s injuries, including the surgeon who repaired his shattered arm with 13 screws and experts who addressed the traumatic brain injury. But one major challenge remained: the most serious damage in the case was also the hardest for jurors to visualize. To solve that problem, the attorneys worked with DK Global to create demonstratives that could show both the mechanics of the fall and the internal brain trauma that followed.

The presentation walked the jury step by step through what happened. It showed Mark’s path along the sidewalk and identified the dangerous elevation defect that interrupted his stride. From there, it illustrated the trip itself and the violent forward fall that followed. The sequence then showed the impact to his arm and the blow to his head as he struck the concrete. From that external event, the visual moved inside the body, depicting how the brain shifted within the skull upon impact. In clear medical terms, the demonstrative helped connect the fall to the internal injury, giving jurors a way to understand that the most devastating harm was not limited to what could be seen from the outside.

Daryoosh and Oliver used the presentation at trial alongside witness testimony, medical evidence, and expert opinions after years of preparation. By that point, the defense was no longer confronting a routine sidewalk claim. It was facing a thoroughly developed case showing a dangerous condition, long-term notice, a serious mechanism of injury, and lasting consequences for the plaintiff. Leading up to trial, the City’s best offer stalled at a mere $100,000. After a three-week trial, the jury found the City of San Diego liable and returned a verdict of more than $4,500,000. Following a motion for costs and fees, the final judgment rose to approximately $4,800,000.

Daryoosh Khashayar has been practicing law for two decades. His firm, Khashayar Law Group, has two locations in San Diego and another in Beverly Hills. Khashayar specializes in personal injury. He has argued cases in superior courts, federal courts, and courts of appeals. He has been a Lawyer of Distinction and recognized as one of the Influential Men of San Diego by San Diego’s Discover Magazine.

Based in San Diego, Oliver Shami has been practicing law for over 30 years, specializing in catastrophic injuries and product defects. Beginning his career as an insurance defense attorney, Oliver shifted his career to focus on plaintiffs and has been exclusively representing them since 1992.

Presenting visuals to a jury can make all the difference and help them understand the true value of the case.

Daryoosh KhashayarKhashayar Law Group

Make Your Case Clear

Build a visual strategy with DK Global.

Contact Us