
Medical Malpractice Leads to Shoulder Dystocia and Nerve Damage in Newborn
Medical negligence during a high-risk vaginal birth results in nerve injuries due to shoulder dystocia.
Watch the Case FeatureMedical professionals in the obstetrics field have a duty to guide their patients through pregnancy toward a healthy birth. They’re responsible for identifying medical defects, complications, and factors that could endanger mothers and babies. At a hospital in Georgia, medical professionals allowed a woman with multiple risk factors to proceed with vaginal delivery during birth when she should have received a cesarean section. Consequently, her baby suffered shoulder dystocia — getting stuck in the mother’s pelvis — resulting in nerve injuries due to the unnecessarily unsafe birth.
The pregnancy was fraught with risk factors from the very beginning. The mother was already heavyset but experienced rapid weight gain during the pregnancy. Additionally, she had unmanaged gestational diabetes. Moreover, doctors identified and documented fetal macrosomia (i.e., large size) and asymmetric fetal growth as the baby developed. These red flags should have led the mother’s care team to recommend a C-section. Unfortunately, doctors allowed the mother to undergo vaginal delivery. As the baby passed through the birth canal, its shoulders lodged behind the mother’s pubic bone. The baby’s neck strained through the mother’s contractions, damaging the delicate newborn’s nerves.
Tina Bullock, an attorney with Bullock Ward Mason, was referred to the client by another attorney. A registered nurse for over 23 years before practicing law, Tina used her hands-on medical experience to shape her case strategy. She knew simplifying her clients’ complex medical stories would be an uphill battle. For instance, Tina predicted that the Defense would try to argue that the baby sustained the shoulder damage in utero, before the birth.
Tina worked with an OBGYN expert to decipher the Plaintiff’s dangerous birthing process and how it led to the baby’s injuries. She quickly realized it would be hard for a jury to understand her expert’s technical medical testimony. To help illustrate what happened to her client, Tina and her medical expert worked with DK Global to create a visual presentation showing her client’s traumatic birth experience and her baby’s subsequent injuries.
The presentation began with an animation of what should have happened to the Plaintiff during her birthing process: a cesarean section. It showed the Plaintiff on the hospital bed, draped with a gown that exposed her lower abdomen. The animation showed an incision to her lower abdomen and how the muscles and fat covering the uterus would have been separated to expose the uterus. The view shifted to the side to show the baby in the womb and how the baby would have been safely extracted through the incision.
Then, the animation depicted the Plaintiff’s actual delivery. It began with notes explaining the risk factors that should have precluded a vaginal birth and that they were ignored in counseling the route of delivery planning. The notes then listed the maneuvers performed during the birth that would have been avoided with a cesarean section, including the McRoberts maneuver, suprapubic pressure, and Wood’s screw. After the notes, the animation again showed the patient on the hospital bed, this time in a position to give vaginal birth. The view shifted to the side to reveal the baby in the uterus, and how the baby’s right shoulder was pinned against the pelvic bone. It then showed the birth, and the three maneuvers to twist and yank the baby out of the uterus. The maneuvers and negligent care resulted in the baby’s damaged shoulder.
Tina Bullock is an attorney and partner at Bullock Ward Mason, a woman-led law firm specializing in medical malpractice, product liability, and hair relaxer cases. After 23 years of clinical hospital experience as an RN, she obtained a B.S. in accounting, followed by a J.D. She is admitted to practice in Georgia, Mississippi, and numerous federal courts. Super Lawyers selected Tina as a Mid-South rising star, and she was nominated as a Top 100 Attorney by the National Trial Lawyers Association.
We were ecstatic with the results that we got, and we think that this will really give us an edge in litigation.