
Heavy Merchandise Falls on Customer from 15 Feet Due to Improper Storage
Ten heavy bags of fertilizer sat loosely in a box high above the shopping aisles of a retailer. Items on upper shelves were required to be shrink-wrapped for safety. However, the box sat unsecured on a wooden pallet…
Watch the Case FeatureTen heavy bags of fertilizer sat loosely in a box high above the shopping aisles of a retailer. Items on upper shelves were required to be shrink-wrapped for safety. However, the box sat unsecured on a wooden pallet. Suddenly, the box collapsed, sending the bags plummeting to the floor below. Directly in the path of the falling fertilizer, a woman was shopping with her mother and sister. Six of the unwieldy bags landed on the victim from 15 feet above. The impact was so violent that the woman lost consciousness and suffered massive injuries, including spinal fractures, heel problems, and a concussion.
With severe injuries and a future of hospitals and medical bills, the woman needed support. She contacted the Indianapolis law firm Andrews & Cox P.C. When she reached out, the firm’s managing partner, John Cox, felt strongly that she needed the best representation possible. To that end, one of the first challenges John needed to overcome was establishing himself with the Defense. Andrew & Cox primarily specialized in collections, so John needed to show the Defense that he was well-versed in personal injury, was taking the case seriously, and was willing to go to trial if necessary.
John acted quickly. He needed to prove liability and damages. The Defense battled every step of the process, initially denying any liability. However, during discovery, John pushed the Defense for information that would have illuminated their culpability. About six months before trial, they backed down and admitted liability. However, the case was far from settled. Damages remained an issue because the victim had low medical bills. At issue, the victim’s injuries were significant and permanent, but there was no surgical option for treatment — only pain management and physical therapy. To that end, what was the value of the Plaintiff’s lifelong pain and suffering — a woman in her early 20’s who could expect to live another 65-70 years?
To quantify his client’s needs, John hired four experts. A force of impact expert explained how much force and damage were caused to the victim. A doctor verified the extent of the injuries and assessed a permanency rating for her injuries. A life care planner determined the financial burden the victim would have to endure. And a vocational economist determined what the victim’s loss of income would look like over the next 50-70 years.
John knew immediately upon taking the case that he would need a visual component. Indeed, he initially did not feel that the case received the appropriate attention from the Defense. So, he reached out to DK Global to collaborate on a pre-suit strategy. John’s goal was to convey the nature and seriousness of the incident, clearly indicate the Defendant’s liability, and have the animation ready to show to a jury if necessary.
Creating the animation was collaborative; it included John, his experts, and DK Global. Initially, it was difficult to fully picture how the accident occurred because there were only a couple pictures of the scene post-incident. In addition, John located a bystander who called 911 after the incident. That person was shown the animation and offered comments or corrections to ensure an accurate reconstruction.
The visual started by showing the box of fertilizer bags sitting on the top shelf and explaining the shrink-wrap safety standard. Next, it highlighted the merchandise that fell, showing how it did not meet the standard. The scene seamlessly shifted to where the victim was standing. Six big bags hit the victim on the head and back with no warning, and she fell to the floor unconscious. Afterward, the height of the merchandise was shown in relation to the Plaintiff —15 feet 10 inches — the distance making her look small. Visuals then displayed accurate, detailed images of the victim’s injuries along with proper medical terminology. Further, it showed how her neck and spine compressed, leading to multiple cervical and thoracic spinal fractures. An internal skull image was shown to display injuries to her eye and her concussion. Several other symptoms the victim suffered from were also depicted. Finally, the video showed the cost of current and potential future medical expenses.
Initially, the Defense refused to provide a settlement offer. However, as John and DK Global developed the animation, the Defense began to cave. At the final pre-trial conference, the Defense filed motions to preclude the video from evidence, demonstrating that they knew the impact it would have had on jurors. Ultimately, after three mediation attempts, the case settled on the eve of trial. The settlement was well within what John and his client hoped for. The highlight for John was the joy and relief the Plaintiff felt knowing her legal ordeal was over.
John Cox is the managing partner of Indianapolis-based Andrews & Cox P.C., where he focuses on collections for lenders and investors in third-party creditors’ rights matters. He has a background in corporate counsel and also has experience in personal injury. John is actively involved in all aspects of the firm’s operations, representing clients across 13 states. John himself is licensed in Indiana, Kentucky, Mississippi, Tennessee, West Virginia, and Florida.
Our job as attorneys is to tell the story of our clients and sometimes words are just not going to be enough...so what we really attempted to do with the visual component is to evoke emotion while telling our story.