POA Receives Favorable Settlement for Defective, Cracked Roadways Using Animated Presentation
Case Features
Reconstruction Animation

POA Receives Favorable Settlement for Defective, Cracked Roadways Using Animated Presentation

The roads deteriorated less than ten years after the project’s completion — cracks and potholes reappeared, and portions of asp

Watch the Case Feature
Open the case feature video

Built in the 1960s, a suburban Southern California residential community offered resort-style, exclusive amenities, including access to a lake, a golf course, and private roadways with gated entries. The community was vast, with over 40 miles of road, funded, constructed, and maintained by a property owners’ association (POA). In 2011, the POA invested $40 million to hire a civil engineering firm to make much-needed repairs to the roads. However, the roads deteriorated less than ten years after the project’s completion — cracks and potholes reappeared, and portions of asphalt became distended — wasting millions of the POA’s funding.

With thousands of POA members frustrated over the negligent construction, the association contacted Daniel Rottinghaus and Howard J. Silldorf of Berding | Weil, LLP. The two retained a team of architects and engineers, and uncovered that the civil engineering firm used two strategies to amend the roadways. In the first strategy, for roads that were still structurally sound, the firm filled fissures with asphalt and applied a layer of asphalt sealant. In the second, for areas with extensive distortion, a complete reconstruction was done. Unfortunately, neither strategy adequately repaired the roads.

The streets that underwent the less-intensive first strategy saw “reflective” cracks form precisely over the old ones. However, the roads that were subject to the more extensive second strategy fared even worse. Roads have two layers over the subgrade dirt: a cement-treated base and a top layer of asphalt. For the latter group of roadways, the firm hired contractors that neglected to install the cement-treated base. A mere three inches of asphalt separated drivers from the subgrade dirt, dramatically speeding erosion. Worse yet, tests revealed that the contractors violated Caltrans standards and used asphalt mixed with recycled fiberglass and other materials that make the pavement too stiff.

With so much complex expert testimony, photographs, and engineering reports, Daniel and Howard needed a strategy to synthesize their case into something easily presentable and understandable. Logically, they brought DK Global onto their team to create a powerful visual demonstrative.

The presentation began with an aerial view of the community, highlighting its private POA-funded road system. Next, DK Global used overhead drone footage of the crumbling streets and outlines of both road rehabilitation strategies. Then, an animated lateral view of the street depicted the Defendant's first approach as they failed to restore the road and adequately seal its fissures, causing water to seep in and soften the subgrade dirt. Another model showed how the engineering firm failed to use a cement-treated foundation and repaved the roads with thin, fragile asphalt. Tests conducted on the asphalt revealed that the contractors used defective materials mixed with fiberglass from roofing shingles, causing the pavement to age rapidly and turn brittle. Finally, both parties' malpractices were laid out alongside the POA’s out-of-pocket expenses.

Daniel and Howard shared the presentation with the Defense counsel and attained a favorable settlement that enabled the POA to fix their roads.

Daniel Rottinghaus has continuously been named a “Super Lawyer” for over ten years, representing commercial and residential real estate clients regarding construction defects. In addition, Daniel has served as a Special Task Force legal advisor for the U.S. State Department and as a Lead attorney for U.S. Army cases involving multi-billion-dollar Iranian claims, earning him the Department of State “Superior Honor Award” in 1993.

For nearly 30 years, Howard J. Silldorf has represented clients throughout Southern California, recovering more than $200 million for his clients in over 100 cases. Howard has earned the Martindale Hubbell Peer Review Rating of “AV Preeminent” for representing his clients in construction defect cases, a prestigious accomplishment attained by attorneys of the highest level of professional excellence.

The way using the DK Global technology gives us an advantage is: a lot of people in our industry haven't yet realized the power that it has. So, we know that we can bring the best result for our client based on using this advanced technology.

Jill Jackson – Berding | Weil LLP

Make Your Case Clear

Build a visual strategy with DK Global.

Contact Us