Man Survives Being Crushed By 30,000-Pound Tractor
Reconstructive Animation Assists Attorney in Premise Liability Case
Read the Full Narration.
Follow the complete spoken story, or use the English captions available in the player.
Show transcript
My name is Martha Dahdah
and I am the founding attorney of Law Office
of Martha Dahdah. I've been practicing in
Riverside for almost 13 years now.
We are located in downtown Riverside very close to the courthouse
My client that we're talking about in this case
his accident
occurred out in South Central Los Angeles
but he came to me because he was referred
by another client that lives here locally in Riverside.
So one of the main issues that we had in this case
was that I did not handle the case from the very beginning.
I came in about eight or nine months after
so he'd had had another lawyer for about seven months
and during the time that
he was with the other lawyer
according to my client,
he was instructed by some staff member
that when he went to
any of the doctors that his lawyer referred him to
to make sure he told him about all his complaints.
But then if he went to
a doctor
maybe through his own insurance for other reasons
like a cold or follow-ups for any other problems
he may have unrelated to the accident
that he should not tell them
about his complaints related to the accident.
And so what compelled us to settle the case was
that he was going to look like a liar.
And that was one of the
biggest obstacles that we had.
Another obstacle we faced was that the former lawyer
neglected to send out a Spoliation of Evidence letter
to the facility where our client was injured
never sent a letter indicating
do not destroy any evidence.
Do not destroy the surveillance footage.
Because there was surveillance footage of this incident.
It was captured on video.
But because his former lawyer
neglected to send out that letter
at some point this footage just mysteriously disappeared.
And so we didn't have that footage
and we were not going to have it for trial
and even though my client repeatedly told me
"They have footage, they told me they had footage,
when I went back a few days later after I got out of the hospital,
They told me they had seen the footage, and that the footage showed you know XYZ,
How come now they don't have it?"
And because that letter was never sent
in the initial stages
we were not going to prevail on having the judge
instruct the jury on destruction of evidence
and so that was another challenge.
Another challenge we had was that at some point last year
the facility was cited
was sent a Notice of Violation from
The City of Los Angeles Building and Safety Department
for not having the proper use permit,
for not having the proper Certificate of Occupancy,
and as a result of having to remedy that
and applying for these proper permits
they had to reconfigure
the entire premises.
So by the time that we retained our liability expert, our safety expert
there was no sense in sending him out
to conduct a site inspection
because the facility had been completely reconfigured
and never did they, did the Defense
or the Defendants inform us
"Hey we have to comply with the City of Los Angeles,
and so we need to reconfigure,
do you want to send someone out
before we do all of this moving around
and reconfiguration of the premises
so that you can preserve what you need for your expert."
So those were some of the major challenges and
because of that and the fact that
they were actually putting fault on the client.
They were saying, "It's his fault
that their 30,000 pound tractor backed into him
in reverse."
That's what compelled me to seek DK Global's help.
because I thought it would be very helpful to be able to show the jury
from our client's perspective,
from his point of view, what happened that day.
So DK Global worked very closely with us,
with the different photos, the Google Earth images we sent,
with the statements that I sent from our client
of how it happened, and you know
the deposition transcript where he clearly explained
how he drove in,
how he backed up,
where he parked, what he did prior to getting crushed,
where he was standing, what he was doing
when he heard this loud roaring noise
and then was crushed.
I thought that was going to be very helpful
for the jury to be able to visualize
that my client had no fault
in getting crushed by a 30,000 pound tractor
that backed up and didn't see him.
Pre-trial motion started on a Wednesday
and we went through all the motions in limine.
I believe we had about eleven motions in limine
and the Defense had about eight motions in limine.
My co-counsel Mary Caruso
argued all of our motions on a Wednesday
and a Thursday afternoon.
We recessed and were ordered to return on a Monday morning
at which time the jury was going to be ready for us
to begin jury selection.
And just before we began jury selection
the case settled. And I think one of the big factors
in helping settle the case was the fact that
Mary Caruso successfully argued the opposition to
the Defense motion in limine
where they wanted to have the mechanism of injury animation excluded.
And so the judge ruled in our favor
and we were going to be allowed
to play the mechanism of injury to the jury.
And I think the Defense was pretty scared of that one.
There was a comment by one of the defense lawyers
that the insurance carrier really, really
was pushing to have that animation excluded.
And so we were very happy when Ms. Caruso
successfully opposed that motion.
And I think that compelled the insurance adjuster
who was present the day
that jury selection was supposed to begin
to put a little more money on the table.
At mediation the most that the Defense offered was $30,000
and the morning of jury selection
they got up to $475,000
and our client accepted that amount.
And so the case is done.